Was Moby Dick based on real historical events
There are many candidates for the title of the ‘Great American Novel’. One of the book’s that is often cited as the greatest American novel of all time is ‘Moby Dick’ (1851). This is one the best-known novel in the English language and has been translated into almost every language. It is perhaps not only the most famous novel about whaling but also the most famous novel about the sea that was ever written. A popular Hollywood movie, starring Gregory Peck, based on the novel was made in 1967 and the work also inspired a mini-series, starring Ethan Hawke (2011). The story of the obsessive Captain Ahab and his pursuit of the White Whale have entered the popular imagination. Was the novel is based on a real-life historical event and figures?
Herman Melville, the author of the novel (1819-1892) was born in New York, into an affluent family, his father a merchant died when he was quite young. This left Melville and his family in a precarious financial position and dependent on relatives. The young man signed up to serve on a whaling ship and went to sea in 1840 on-board a whaling ship. In the 19th century, whales were hunted for their oil. While at sea the young Melville had many adventures. In 1841, he jumped ship in Tahiti and later joined another whaler. He became involved in a mutiny on board this ship and was briefly jailed.
Melville served as an ordinary seaman on a US Navy frigate before he eventually returned home. Soon he became a full-time writer and had great success with his first novel Typee, based on his own adventures. His later works were not commercially successful and the book that he is best known for, Moby Dick was a complete failure. Melville was obliged to work as a custom’s official and continued to write poetry and prose, but they were largely ignored. He died penniless and forgotten in 1891 in New York. Since then his fame has grown and his novels, short stories, and poems are regarded not only as classics of American literature but of World literature.
The plot of the novel
The novel opens with the narrator Ishmael looking for a ship, he is a man who is seeking a purpose in life. He signs up to serve on a whaling ship the Pequod in Nantucket. The captain of the ship is Ahab, who over the course of the novel is shown to be unstable man possessed with a desir top kill the white whale. Ishmael meets a host of colorful characters on-board the ship including Queequeg, and Fedallah, both harpooners. Captain Ahab has lost his leg in an encounter with a gigantic white sperm whale and he is consumed by a desire for revenge. He nails a gold coin to the mast and states that he will give it to the first man who sees the whale, the legendary Moby Dick. Ishmael soon realizes that this is not a typical whaling mission but a revenge mission.
The Pequod sails around the globe, hunting whales, but Ahab is only interested in finding Moby Dick. The ships have a number of adventures including being battered by a typhoon in the Pacific. One of the crew members prophesized that the whale will kill Ahab, this does not deter the one-legged captain and he continues to pursue his vendetta. During the search, they hear tales of the great white whale and in one instance they learn that it has recently sunk a ship. Finally, the Captain himself sees the whale and there begins a brutal three-day encounter between Ahab, his men, and Moby Dick. On the first day, the captain and his crew attack the whale with harpoons from small boats, but the white whale smashes the boat and nearly kills Ahab. Several sailors are lost that day.
The following day Ahab and his crew again try and slaughter the whale but again it sinks the boats. On the third day, the captain once again, engages with Moby Dick, during this the whale is killed and Ahab also dies. The Pequod is badly damaged and sinks, and the only survivor is Ishmael, he floats in a wooden coffin until he is rescued.
The adventures of Herman Melville
Melville was at sea for several years and had served on two whalers. During the mid-19th century, whaling was a huge industry and it employed tens of thousands of American sailors and was critical to the economy of the North-East of the United States. Melville’s description of life aboard a whaling ship is very accurate as a result. The manner in which the sailors lived and the difficult conditions that they endured are all very realistic. Many of the details of the Pequod are based on Melville’s own time spend on the whaler Acushnet. This ship was owned by a Quaker who may have been the model for the character Bildad. The crew of the ship that Melville served on was very diverse, they included Africans, Europeans, and Americans, and many may have served as models for some of his most memorable creations. Some critics believe that the diverse crew served as a symbol for America and its many different ethnicities and groups.
The literary tradition
Melville was a great creative writer and was a voracious reader and like every other author, he was part of a literary tradition. His imagination and his literary influences included Shakespeare, Homer and the Bible. Much of the work is based on the imagination of the author and his preoccupations. Moby Dick is a work that is very symbolic and one of its main themes according to many critics is the search for God. Ahab is possibly passed on the Israelite king who led the Hebrews away from the Lord. He was a worshipper of idols and many, readers in the 19th century would have, interpreted Ahab’s obsession with the whale as a form of idolatry and sinful. It is important to note that Melville was brought up in a strict Calvinist household.
This is only one of the readings of the books, which is remarkably complex. Another influence on the work is Shakespeare, many believe that Ahab was based on great tragic heroes such as King Lear and Macbeth. Another possible model for the one-legged captain was the character of Satan, in Milton’s epic poem Paradise Lost. Melville was also greatly influenced by non-fiction works, these included the famous Two Years Before the Mast.
Sinking of the Essex
Many historians and Melville scholars believe that the main model for the Pequod and the story of Moby Dick was the tragic fate of the Essex. This was an American whaler from Nantucket, Massachusetts. It was a very successful whaler and it was owned by a number of local citizens, which was the custom of the time. In 1820, the ship was hunting whales in the South Pacific and it was under the command of a Captain George Pollard.
While hunting, a huge sperm whale attacked the vessel. The Essex was so badly damaged by the mammal that it could not sail. The 20 men on board had little food and even less water and forced to leave the sinking ship in small boats in the hope of reaching land, but they were thousands of miles for the coast of South America. The crew had no food and began to starve and in desperation, they began to eat the bodies of those who died in the boat. When there were no more corpses to eat, the crew drew lots as to who would be killed and cannibalized.
In total, the records differ, some seven or eight men were eaten by their crewmates. They were eventually rescued by a passing British ship. Only eight men, out of the original crew of twenty, survived. Some of the survivors left an account of the sinking of the Essex and their privations. The most popular account was written by Owen Chase, who was the first mate on the doomed ship. It appears that Melville read this work, Narrative of the Most Extraordinary and Distressing Shipwreck of the Whale-Ship Essex and even met Chase’ son. There are striking similarities between the fate of the Essex and the Pequod. In both, whalers were attacked by huge sperm whales which led to the loss of life. However, there are some differences, the chief one is that there is no cannibalism in the 1851 book. In 2015 a movie ‘In the heart of the Sea’ was made based on the crew of the Essex.
In the book, a gigantic white whale attacked the Pequod and sank it, killing all the crew, except Ishmael. In the 19th century, there were several instances of, mainly sperm whales attacking whalers, but they were very rare. However, more ships were damaged or sank after collisions with the mammals. Among one of the well-known examples of this whale, attacks were the Essex. Anbother possible model for the white whale was Mocha Dick. This was an albino sperm whale who was described as gigantic and coated with barnacles and was very aggressive. He lived in the waters of the Pacific Ocean, off the coast of Chile, and was often seen near the Island of Mocha. This was how he came to be named as Mocha Dick and he was an astonishing 100 feet long.
The whale had possibly up to 100 encounters with whalers and he may have survived all of them.  Sometimes, if he did not feel threatened he would meekly swim net to a ship. If he was threatened by a harpooner he would strike boats with his massive fluke (at the end of his tail) or leap from the water and fall on the vessel. The whale became something of a legend, especially among mariners in Massachusetts. It was claimed that he was killed in 1838 and that it took twenty harpoons to kill him. However, it was also reported that he was seen in the Arctic. There were many reports of huge white sperm whales in the 19th century and Mocha Dick was not unique. There are undoubted similarities between this whale and Moby Dick, such as its color, size, and aggression. It seems that Melville was aware of the story and it inspired him when he was writing his most memorable novel.
Moby Dick is an amazing read and its plot and language make it a unique piece of art. One of the reasons why the book is so memorable was its detail and its realistic depictions of life on a whaling ship and the dangers of whaling in the 19th century. Melville’s great work is so powerful because it is in large part based on actual historical events that the author actually experiences and witnesses. Moby Dick offers great insight into the whaling industry in the 19th century. Melville appears to have based many of the characters he created on his old shipmates. It also seems that he was greatly influenced by the tragic fate of the Essex and its crew. However, he only used elements of the story.
It is almost certain that he had heard of the remarkable Mocha Dick and other huge white sperm whales. The tales of Mocha Dick no doubt, inspired the American writer in the creation of perhaps the most famous novel of the sea. However, the story of Moby Dick was also greatly influenced by the literary tradition, especially Shakespeare. The magnum opus of the New York-born author was also inspired by the bible, evident in its symbolism. The reader should see Moby Dick as a composite of real historical events and the imagination of its author.
Bercaw, Mary K. Melville's Sources (Evanston, Illinois: Northwestern University Press, 1987).
Heimert, Alan. "Moby-Dick and American Political Symbolism." American Quarterly 15, no. 4 (1963): 498-534.
Kelley, Wyn (ed.). (2006). A Companion to Herman Melville. Blackwell Publishing
- Delbanco, Andrew, Melville: His World and Work (New York: Knopf, 2005), p 23
- Delbanco, p 145
- Delbanco, p 112
- Melville, Herman, Moby-Dick (London, Penguin Books, 2012)
- Talley, Sharon. Student Companion to Herman Melville. Westport, Connecticut: Greenwood Press, 2007), p 19
- Sten, Christopher. Sounding the Whale: Moby-Dick as Epic Novel (Ohio, New Kent State University Press, 1996), p 115
- Delbanco, Andrew. Melville: His World and Work. New York: Knopf, 2005), p 113
- Brodhead, Richard H., ed. New Essays on Moby-Dick (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 1986), p 118
- Severin, Timothy, and Tim Serverin. In search of Moby Dick: Quest for the white whale (London, Little, Brown, 1999), p. 18
- Severein, p. 121
- Severein, p.99
- Severein, p 118